Friday 30 August 2013

Competence: Public Vs Private University Graduates

Recent research done on the competence of graduates from public and private university have given those from private universities a due advantage in the job market. The research may have some weight in it but I fail to understand whether it is true across all the courses. This makes me wonder how those who got high grades in KCSE get to be outdone by those who got average grades. If the research is something to believe then there is something wrong somewhere or some people have failed to undertake their responsibilities. Is it not true that public universities have the best brains from all over the country? Could it be that these good brains are being wasted in public universities? Many reasons have been given for the deteriorating standards in public universities. Less commitment by both lecturers and students, insufficient academic facilities among others. Does this apply to all courses? Generalising that students from public universities are less competent as compared to those from private universities could be propagating a lie. Many recent graduates from public universities have been doing well in their jobs. Does the research put them into consideration?
Lets take a look at the recent media probe on those doctors who have put the lives of Kenyans at a risk. If somebody could tell me whether they did medicine in public or private universities then probably we could have a clear picture of the reality. I have no doubts where the fake doctors did their degrees but has anybody come out to condemn the institutions where that natured them? Some will say it is unethical to do so. Does that mean that putting the lives of Kenyans at risk is ethical? The painful truth is that universities are admitting students for courses that are beyond their academic abilities. We all appreciate that private universities offer those who were unable to obtain JAB cut off points but offering them courses that are beyond their academic ability. Though it may be sceptical but I fail to understand how one who can deal with complex biology in medicine when the simple secondary school biology was a problem understanding. Could it be logical for one to comfortably tackle the complex physics in an Engineering course when the simple physics in high school was an uphill task?  The instances of collapsing buildings under construction supervised by incompetent Engineersand loss of lives in the hands of these incompetent doctor is a clear evidence of the effects of undertaking degree courses beyond one’s academic ability.
Though every student in a public university would agree that there is great need for changes and improvements in those institutions, generalising that students from private universities are more competent as compared to their counterparts from public universities holds little water especially in some courses.
Recent research done on the competence of graduates from public and private university have given those from private universities a due advantage in the job market. The research may have some weight in it but I fail to understand whether it is true across all the courses. This makes me wonder how those who got high grades in KCSE get to be outdone by those who got average grades. If the research is something to believe then there is something wrong somewhere or some people have failed to undertake their responsibilities. Is it not true that public universities have the best brains from all over the country? Could it be that these good brains are being wasted in public universities? Many reasons have been given for the deteriorating standards in public universities. Less commitment by both lecturers and students, insufficient academic facilities among others. Does this apply to all courses? Generalising that students from public universities are less competent as compared to those from private universities could be propagating a lie. Many recent graduates from public universities have been doing well in their jobs. Does the research put them into consideration?
Lets take a look at the recent media probe on those doctors who have put the lives of Kenyans at a risk. If somebody could tell me whether they did medicine in public or private universities then probably we could have a clear picture of the reality. I have no doubts where the fake doctors did their degrees but has anybody come out to condemn the institutions where that natured them? Some will say it is unethical to do so. Does that mean that putting the lives of Kenyans at risk is ethical? The painful truth is that universities are admitting students for courses that are beyond their academic abilities. We all appreciate that private universities offer those who were unable to obtain JAB cut off points but offering them courses that are beyond their academic ability. Though it may be sceptical but I fail to understand how one who can deal with complex biology in medicine when the simple secondary school biology was a problem understanding. Could it be logical for one to comfortably tackle the complex physics in an Engineering course when the simple physics in high school was an uphill task?  The instances of collapsing buildings under construction supervised by incompetent Engineersand loss of lives in the hands of these incompetent doctor is a clear evidence of the effects of undertaking degree courses beyond one’s academic ability.
Though every student in a public university would agree that there is great need for changes and improvements in those institutions, generalising that students from private universities are more competent as compared to their counterparts from public universities holds little water especially in some courses.